Showing posts with label Medical Laboratory Quality Management. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Medical Laboratory Quality Management. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 26, 2017

Motivation and Inspiration in Quality Teaching




I have a personal story about my quality adventure.  I have mentioned it before, but it is worth repeating. 

 In 2002 I was shamed into pursuing international recognition for CMPT, my proficiency testing program by a laboratory technologist who accused me and others associated with laboratory oversight as being FRAUDS because we exerted our authority over laboratories making performance demands while at the same time requiring no similar demands on ourselves.  She was disturbingly  but absolutely correct because back then neither my province nor my country required or expected either  accreditation bodies or proficiency testing bodies to demonstrate competence through objective oversight.
  
In the absence of an established credible laboratory quality standard (at the time) we immediately started our process towards have our quality system developed and certified to ISO9001:2000. 

[Note: while ILAC guide 25 for testing laboratories and ILAC guide 43 for proficiency testing bodies existed, there were no Canadian bodies that would assess against either guideline at the time. There were however Canadian certification bodies that could assess against ISO9001].


In order to implement our voluntarily imposed quality system, we hired a quality consultant but things were not going well.  One day he called me aside and pointed out that when he was around, I would work with him on the QMS.  When he was NOT around I would STOP working.  Josef made it clear: “This was NOT his QMS, and was NOT his laboratory.  If I wanted this to actually happen, I would have to take ownership and get my act in gear”.  Again, he was right and I was definitely wrong.
With the appropriate well placed kick, we got ourselves going, completed our certification and have maintained it ever since, most recently to ISO9001:2015. 
By every measure CMPT improved substantially and has grown from being a local program to a national and now international EQA provider.  In 2014 we extended our commitment to quality and added international accreditation (ISO/IEC17043:2010).


The reason that I recount this story is because it is a very personal good example of a general truth: the impetus and inspiration to Quality can come from the most unexpected of places, but the drive and motivation to Quality must come from within.   

The story has relevance for me because over the years we taken that same passion and commitment and put it into creating our Certificate Course in Laboratory Quality Management.  We have now trained close to 400 people.  Most have come from Canada or the United States or some of the wealthy developed countries in the middle East.  Some have come from much less wealthy regions. 

While about 95 percent do well enough to earn their certificate and by survey enjoy what we offer, by my estimate less than half leave the course with the sort of commitment and drive to make an inspired career in the Quality arena.   


We occasionally get folks that folks who come uninspired and leave uninspired.  Recently we had a person, very senior in laboratory hierarchy, who paid the tuition money, started the course but hardly ever participated and then quit showing up after about a month and then just disappeared.  I wonder how the employer felt about frittered money. 

I will tell you that every once in a while, we get a note that something has happened and they were unable to continue. Sometimes we can offer a rebate, or an invitation to come back and continue next year.  In this situation, they didn’t ask and we didn’t offer.

But because we are aware of  and pay attention to those who don’t move forward, we spend a lot of time and energy focusing on course improvements and the changing picture of quality.  We promote leadership and innovation and their impact on culture of quality and the development of quality tools.  We focus as much (or more) attention on challenging participants to look for and find positive and progressive opportunities for improvement as we charge them to monitor and identify and remediate and correct findings of non-conformities.


And sometimes we get our special rewards for the effort when we receive letters and notes from the enthusiastic participants who tell us about how our course inspired them to take their laboratory quality to the next level.  


So here is the point that I am making.  Despite our efforts at continual improvement and promoting communication and participation and learning and teaching new skills, taking our course can not guarantee to imbue all participants with the drive and motivation to engage in quality passionately, but I sure am pleased that we have been able to provide more than our fair share with the impetus and drive (and in some instances, passion) to help make laboratories better.

There is much to be gained being committed to providing quality Quality education. 






Saturday, May 18, 2013

ASM Quality Workshop



ASM Quality Workshop
Today we participated in the Quality Workshop at the Annual General Meeting (ASM) for the American Society for Microbiology.  In some respects this is the perfect union.  The ASM attracts about a bazillion people from around the world.  It is big enough to fill almost every hotel in Denver.  The Quality Workshop is a bit of a niche interest, but we managed to have people from across the US, Canada Lebanon, South Africa, Australia and the Republic of Cameroon.  Small conferences will attract interested folks, and mega-meetings will attract broad international crowds.  We were lucky to end up with the best of both.

Without wanting to overstate the situation, I think the light has gone on  in the United States.  While at one time the CLIA regulations were the vanguard leaders in the world, many would say at 25 years old, CLIA has become a tired millstone in serious need of revision.  While there are many US laboratories that don’t give a damn to quality, those that are recognize that being accredited to CLIA provides no evidence of interest in making their laboratory better.  

Fast, cheap, east, mandatory and sufficient; good-enough is good-enough.

The folks that attended the workshop were of a different mindset; interested in learning about international quality, with higher aspirations for their laboratory’s reputation and recognition.

The meeting was put together by CDC and included two CDC speakers, a well-informed speaker from another laboratory and me.  One can find the names of the other speakers by going to the ASM Annual General Meeting site and looking for speakers at workshop WS:04.

It was an excellent meeting full of practical tips, and perspective. 

I gave a good overview of why Quality Management belongs in every laboratory. 
 A very good presentation was given on CLSI and that organization’s participation in the Quality area.  A very good crosswalk was presented on how CLSI guidelines lined up with the requirements of ISO standards.  It was pretty clear that CLSI is contributing to US medical laboratories by providing a series of documents that help implement Quality.   

What was really interesting to me was the presentation on measurement uncertainty from a laboratory in the US that had decided to get accredited to ISO/IEC 17025 very early on, had has had to struggle with MU.  A model for application of MU for quantitation of urine cultures was presented.  

I thought it truly excellent.  We all agreed that MU is an irrelevant waste of time, but has to be dealt with if a laboratory wants to benefit from the achievement of ISO accreditation.  Having to jump through hoops purely to satisfy accreditation bodies may be stupid and evil, but it unfortunately an unavoidable stupid evil.    What Alice presented was a model that would get it done in as painless a manner possible.  And that probably is the best way forward.  

And more to the point, the information is generated solely for internal  holding.  Do not present the information to anyone, other than the accrediting body. 
What I thought amusing was her mentioning that the accrediting body required her to actually to through the arithmetic during their site visit.  Just sad.

The last presentation was unfortunately cut short because so many questions were being asked.  It was too bad because it was shaping up as an excellent presentation fo some practical tips on implementing Quality on an voluntary level.  As mentioned, it your laboratory is not going to go for full ISO accreditation, you are still better off implementing some easy steps along the way, and gradually building your Quality inventory.  It is not the best way to implement Quality but if management and staff are committed, it can work.  I am thinking of inviting her to give the presentation again in Vancouver at the POLQM Medical Laboratory Quality Conference Meeting October 16-17-18 2013.

If you want to meeting an impressive faculty, plan to come to the meeting.  If you want to learn and discuss and debate Quality with peers, plan to come to the meeting.  It you want to participate in a World Standards Day celebration, plan to come to the meeting.

More info VERY SOON.

M

Sunday, May 5, 2013

Is Accreditation the only way?



Over my career I have had a bipolar relationship with medical laboratory accreditation bodies.  On the one side I see accreditation when it performs its functions as an external assessment body as an important and valued partner for laboratory Quality.  Being an outside set of eyes with both an understanding of Quality and laboratory practices and armed with an established standard such as ISO 15189:2012 or ISO/IEC17025:2005 or one of the related documents that has been adapted from the parent document and used on a local or regional basis, accreditation bodies can be powerful supporters of the laboratory Quality performance.

On the other side I have been particularly critical when accreditation bodies believe it is within their purview to write or cherry pick their own standards or when they allow for loose understanding and even looser interpretation by peer reviewers.  Any assessor who starts an accreditation observation with the phrase “Well in my laboratory we do it this way…” is a bad assessor should be terminated immediately.  I don’t care what someone does in their laboratory; I need to know if my laboratory is meeting the word and spirit of the established standard. 

And it irks me when folks who have never worked in a laboratory or have no recent understanding of laboratory activity believe they are appropriate persons to be take authority for creating standards. 

And I really fatigue of Accreditation Bodies that year over year a hundred percent success rate on laboratory accreditation.  While I don’t think it is nice that some laboratories are closed and people lose their jobs or hospitals or communities are inconvenienced, I find it far worse when weak laboratories are given admonitions, knowing full well that nothing is going to happen.  If a laboratory has a poor performance, it is far better than the inconvenient thing happen and the problems get addressed rather than wait for the horrific failure to occur. 

And what especially annoys me is the verbiage that says that Accreditation can assess the competence of a laboratory.  What total nonsense.  Accreditation visits are staged events, barely longer than a Broadway play.  The notion that a group of people can come into a laboratory on a given day and make anything other than superficial commentary on the activities of the people working on that day is a good example of a hallucinatory pipedream.

Recently I was in discussion with a person with responsibility and authority and commented that the olden days the technical requirements of a laboratory were both manual and working knowledge based.  Laboratory workers need a lot of hands-on skills and accurate recall of intricate data.  Today’s laboratory is different;  autoanalysers have taken over most of the manual and mental skills, leaving staff requiring a new skills focused mainly on computer and data handling.  In the olden days, laboratory workers needed to be able to manually maintain hardware and sometimes ripping it apart and then repairing it.  No longer.  Equipment these days needs service experts or more often, is just swapped out. 

Skill sets come in two categories, routine and crisis intervention.  Both work well the vast majority of time, with the rare and irregular slip and/or distraction that leads to error.  The reality is slips and distractions do not lend themselves to measurement for competence on a given day by a given group no matter how clever they are.  Most site visits will never occur on the day that an error happens.

What accreditation bodies look these days is evidence that Quality Control and the Quality System are intact and being followed faithfully The accreditation body is determining if the organization is meeting its laboratory-relevant Quality system in a manner than is likely to detect error early, remediate it and correct it before ensuing harm spreads beyond the confines of the laboratory.  Not to belabour the point, but we have groups that look at whether or not an organization’s Quality system is intact: we call them Certification Bodies.   

So while the accreditation bodies often view certification bodies as their inferior and evil twins, the reality is that by and large to two groups provide the same function.  And if that is the case, do we really need both?

From my personal perspective, I find that the Certification Body that visits CMPT on an annual basis, provides a demanding review of our Quality System and Quality Control.  They don’t have the time or experience or knowledge to sit and watch as we go through the tasks related to planning or creating or transporting our PT samples, no do they sit in as we go through the evaluation process.  They find and examine the secondary evidence that supports that we are doing our tasks well.  Our adoption and regular assessment to ISO 9001:2008 has made us very effective PT provider. 

At a certain point medical laboratories authorities may want to ask if assessment of Quality and Competence can only be done one way.